Backlog vs Smartsheet
Detailed side-by-side comparison
Backlog
FreeBacklog is an all-in-one project management platform specifically designed for development teams, combining issue tracking, built-in Git/SVN version control, and collaboration tools in a single workspace. It excels at bridging the gap between code management and project tracking with strong integrations between repositories and issue workflows.
Visit BacklogSmartsheet
FreeSmartsheet is a collaborative work management platform that uses a familiar spreadsheet-like interface to deliver powerful project management, automation, and reporting capabilities. It's designed for broad enterprise use across multiple departments and industries, offering flexibility and ease of adoption without requiring technical expertise.
Visit SmartsheetFeature Comparison
| Feature | Backlog | Smartsheet |
|---|---|---|
| Version Control | Built-in Git and SVN repositories directly integrated with issue tracking, allowing seamless linking of commits to issues | No native version control; relies on integrations with external tools like GitHub, GitLab, or Bitbucket |
| Project Visualization | Gantt charts and burndown charts focused on development workflows and sprint tracking | Multiple view options including Grid, Gantt, Calendar, and Card views with dynamic dashboards and customizable widgets for various visualization needs |
| Automation | Customizable workflows for issue and bug tracking with notifications and status transitions | Robust automated workflows with approval processes, conditional logic, and extensive trigger-based actions to reduce manual work |
| Collaboration Tools | Comments, notifications, wikis for documentation, and file sharing with version management | Real-time collaboration with comments, attachments, @mentions, and proofing capabilities across multiple users simultaneously |
| Integration Ecosystem | Focused integrations primarily for development tools and version control workflows | Extensive integration library with 100+ apps including Microsoft, Google Workspace, Slack, Salesforce, and enterprise systems |
| Resource Management | Basic resource allocation through issue assignment and workload tracking within projects | Advanced resource management and capacity planning features with allocation tracking across multiple projects and teams |
Pricing Comparison
Both tools offer free starter plans, but pricing structures differ significantly as teams scale. Smartsheet typically becomes more expensive for advanced features and larger teams, while Backlog's costs increase with team size but offer better value for development-focused teams needing integrated version control.
Verdict
Choose Backlog if...
Choose Backlog if you're a software development team that needs tight integration between version control (Git/SVN) and issue tracking, or if you want an all-in-one solution specifically built for managing code-centric projects with built-in wikis and repositories.
Choose Smartsheet if...
Choose Smartsheet if you need a flexible work management platform that works across multiple departments and use cases beyond software development, require powerful automation and extensive third-party integrations, or prefer a spreadsheet-familiar interface that's easy for non-technical teams to adopt.
Get Your Free Software Recommendation
Answer a few quick questions and we'll match you with the perfect tools
Select the category that best fits your needs
Pros & Cons
Backlog
Pros
- + Comprehensive all-in-one solution combining project management and version control
- + Intuitive interface with powerful Gantt chart capabilities
- + Strong integration between code repositories and issue tracking
- + Excellent for Japanese and international teams with multilingual support
Cons
- - Can be expensive for larger teams compared to competitors
- - Learning curve for teams unfamiliar with integrated project management tools
- - Limited customization options compared to more flexible platforms like Jira
Smartsheet
Pros
- + Intuitive spreadsheet-like interface makes adoption easy for all skill levels
- + Highly flexible and customizable for various use cases and industries
- + Robust automation capabilities reduce manual work and errors
- + Enterprise-grade security with SOC 2 Type II compliance and advanced controls
Cons
- - Pricing can become expensive as team size grows, especially for advanced features
- - Steep learning curve for advanced features like complex formulas and automations
- - Mobile app functionality is limited compared to desktop experience