Big Cartel vs Gumroad
Detailed side-by-side comparison
Big Cartel
FreeBig Cartel is an ecommerce platform built specifically for artists, makers, and creators who want to sell physical creative products through their own branded online store. It emphasizes simplicity and aesthetic design with customizable themes, supporting up to 500 products without charging transaction fees.
Visit Big CartelGumroad
FreeGumroad is a creator-focused e-commerce platform that specializes in selling digital products, memberships, and subscriptions directly to audiences. It combines product delivery, payment processing, and marketing tools in one simple package, making it ideal for creators who want to monetize digital content with minimal setup.
Visit GumroadFeature Comparison
| Feature | Big Cartel | Gumroad |
|---|---|---|
| Product Types | Primarily designed for physical products from artists and makers, with inventory management for up to 500 items | Optimized for digital products, memberships, and subscriptions, with automatic digital delivery and hosting included |
| Store Customization | Offers customizable themes and design options with custom domain support for a fully branded storefront experience | Provides customizable product pages and checkout but with more limited storefront branding and design flexibility |
| Marketing Tools | No built-in email marketing tools; requires third-party integrations for audience communication | Includes built-in email marketing and audience building tools to communicate directly with customers and grow your fanbase |
| Payment Processing | Integrates with PayPal and Stripe; charges no transaction fees on any plan | Built-in payment processing with transaction-based fees; no monthly fees on free tier but higher per-transaction costs |
| Membership & Subscriptions | Limited subscription capabilities; primarily focused on one-time product purchases | Robust membership and subscription management system with recurring billing and exclusive content delivery |
| Affiliate Programs | No built-in affiliate program management; would require external tools or manual tracking | Includes built-in affiliate program management to let others promote your products for commission |
Pricing Comparison
Both platforms offer free plans to start, making them accessible to creators just beginning their selling journey. Big Cartel's paid plans eliminate transaction fees and work better for higher-volume sellers, while Gumroad's transaction-based model (no monthly fee) is more flexible for creators with inconsistent sales but becomes more expensive as volume increases.
Verdict
Choose Big Cartel if...
Choose Big Cartel if you're an artist or maker selling physical products who wants a beautifully designed, branded online store with no transaction fees. It's ideal for creators who prioritize aesthetics and plan to process a consistent volume of orders.
Choose Gumroad if...
Choose Gumroad if you're selling digital products, memberships, or subscriptions and want an all-in-one solution with built-in email marketing and audience management. It's perfect for creators who want the simplest possible setup and don't mind paying per-transaction instead of monthly fees.
Get Your Free Software Recommendation
Answer a few quick questions and we'll match you with the perfect tools
Select the category that best fits your needs
Pros & Cons
Big Cartel
Pros
- + Extremely user-friendly with minimal learning curve
- + Affordable pricing tailored for independent artists and small creators
- + No transaction fees on any plan
- + Clean, artist-focused design aesthetic
Cons
- - Limited advanced ecommerce features compared to larger platforms
- - No built-in email marketing tools
- - Fewer app integrations and third-party extensions
Gumroad
Pros
- + Extremely simple setup with no technical knowledge required
- + No monthly fees on the free tier, only transaction-based pricing
- + Built-in email marketing and customer relationship tools
- + Strong community of creators and comprehensive resources
Cons
- - Higher transaction fees compared to traditional e-commerce platforms
- - Limited customization options for storefronts and branding
- - Fewer integrations with third-party tools than competitors