S

Box vs Carbonite

Detailed side-by-side comparison

Box

Box

Free

Box is an enterprise-grade cloud content management platform focused on secure collaboration, file sharing, and workflow automation. It offers unlimited storage across all paid plans and integrates with over 1,500 business applications, making it ideal for teams that need advanced security controls and compliance features.

Visit Box
Carbonite

Carbonite

From $6/mo

Carbonite is a cloud backup solution designed for automatic, continuous data protection with unlimited storage options. It focuses primarily on backing up files and systems with strong recovery capabilities, serving both businesses and individuals who need reliable disaster recovery.

Visit Carbonite

Feature Comparison

FeatureBoxCarbonite
Primary PurposeContent management, collaboration, and file sharing with real-time co-editing and workflow automationAutomated continuous backup and disaster recovery with system-level protection
Storage CapacityUnlimited storage on all paid plans; 10GB on free tierUnlimited cloud storage on most plans
Collaboration FeaturesReal-time co-editing, task assignments, comments, Box Sign for e-signatures, and workflow automation with Box RelayRemote file access only; no collaboration or co-editing features
Security & ComplianceEnterprise-grade security with granular permissions, encryption, and compliance certifications (HIPAA, FINRA, FedRAMP)Military-grade encryption for data protection during backup and storage
Integration EcosystemIntegrates with 1,500+ apps including Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, Slack, and other business toolsLimited integrations; primarily standalone backup solution
Recovery OptionsFile versioning and restoration through content management interfaceMultiple recovery options including web download, courier recovery service for large data sets, and external hard drive backup

Pricing Comparison

Box starts with a free tier but paid plans are more expensive, targeting enterprise customers who need collaboration and compliance features. Carbonite starts at $6/month with a focus on affordable backup solutions, making it more budget-friendly for individuals and small businesses needing basic data protection.

Verdict

Choose Box if...

Choose Box if you need a collaborative content management platform with real-time editing, workflow automation, extensive integrations, and enterprise-grade security compliance. It's ideal for teams that actively work together on documents and require sophisticated permission controls.

Choose Carbonite if...

Choose Carbonite if your primary need is automatic, continuous backup and disaster recovery for your files and systems. It's best for individuals or businesses that want set-it-and-forget-it data protection without collaboration features, especially if budget is a concern.

Get Your Free Software Recommendation

Answer a few quick questions and we'll match you with the perfect tools

1/4

Select the category that best fits your needs

Cloud Storage

Pros & Cons

Box

Pros

  • + Enterprise-grade security with granular permissions and compliance features (HIPAA, FINRA, FedRAMP)
  • + Unlimited storage on all paid plans, including individual accounts
  • + Robust integration ecosystem with native apps for productivity tools
  • + Advanced collaboration features including task assignments and workflow automation

Cons

  • - More expensive than consumer-focused alternatives like Dropbox or Google Drive
  • - Interface can feel complex for individual users or small teams
  • - Limited functionality on the free tier with only 10GB storage

Carbonite

Pros

  • + Unlimited storage on most plans
  • + Easy setup and automatic operation
  • + Strong encryption and security features
  • + Multiple recovery options including courier delivery

Cons

  • - Can be slow for initial backup of large data sets
  • - Limited version history compared to competitors
  • - Higher pricing compared to some alternatives