Decimal vs Square

Detailed side-by-side comparison

Decimal

From $1500/mo

Decimal is a full-service accounting and finance platform built specifically for startups and high-growth companies. It combines bookkeeping technology with dedicated accounting teams and CFO advisory services to deliver investor-grade financial reporting and strategic guidance.

Visit Decimal

Square

Free

Square is a payment processing and point-of-sale platform designed for businesses that need to accept payments and manage sales operations. It offers an integrated ecosystem of hardware and software for in-person and online transactions, serving retailers, restaurants, and service businesses.

Visit Square

Feature Comparison

Feature	Decimal	Square
Core Purpose	Provides full-service accounting, bookkeeping, and CFO advisory with human experts managing financial operations	Enables payment processing and point-of-sale operations with tools for accepting customer payments and tracking sales
Financial Reporting	Delivers real-time investor-grade financial dashboards with automated month-end close and strategic insights from finance professionals	Offers sales reporting and analytics focused on transaction data, inventory, and revenue tracking
Human Support	Includes dedicated accounting team and CFO advisory services as core offering with proactive financial guidance	Provides customer support for technical issues but no dedicated financial advisors or accounting teams
Integration Ecosystem	Integrates with QuickBooks, Xero, and major banking platforms to centralize financial data for accounting purposes	Integrates payments, POS, payroll, and accounting tools within Square's ecosystem plus third-party business software
Tax and Compliance	Includes tax preparation and compliance support as part of the accounting service with expert guidance	Generates tax reports from sales data and offers payroll tax filing, but does not provide full tax preparation services
Target User	Startups and high-growth companies needing professional accounting services and financial strategy support	Retailers, restaurants, and service businesses of all sizes needing payment processing and sales management tools

Pricing Comparison

Decimal starts at $1,500/month reflecting its premium full-service accounting model with human experts, while Square offers a free tier with pay-per-transaction pricing that scales with usage. The tools serve entirely different purposes, making direct pricing comparison less relevant than evaluating the value each provides for its specific use case.

Verdict

Choose Decimal if...

Choose Decimal if you're a startup or high-growth company needing professional accounting services, CFO-level financial guidance, and investor-grade reporting with dedicated experts managing your books. It's ideal when you want to outsource your entire finance function to experienced professionals.

Choose Square if...

Choose Square if you need to accept payments, run a point-of-sale system, or manage retail/restaurant operations with integrated payment processing. It's perfect for businesses focused on transaction processing, inventory management, and sales operations rather than comprehensive accounting services.

Get Your Free Software Recommendation

Answer a few quick questions and we'll match you with the perfect tools

1/4

What type of software are you looking for?

Select the category that best fits your needs

Accounting

Pros & Cons

Decimal

Pros

+ Combines technology with expert human accountants for accuracy
+ Purpose-built for startups with investor-grade reporting
+ Proactive financial guidance from experienced finance professionals
+ Streamlined onboarding and migration from existing systems

Cons

- Higher price point compared to basic bookkeeping software
- May be overkill for very small businesses or solopreneurs
- Limited to U.S.-based companies

Square

Pros

+ No monthly fees for the free tier with simple per-transaction pricing
+ Easy setup with minimal technical knowledge required
+ Comprehensive ecosystem integrating payments, POS, and accounting
+ Reliable hardware options with seamless software integration

Cons

- Transaction fees can be higher than some competitors for high-volume businesses
- Limited customization options compared to enterprise solutions
- Account holds and fund freezes reported by some users during disputes