Thinkific vs Udemy
Detailed side-by-side comparison
Thinkific
FreeThinkific is a course creation platform that enables instructors and entrepreneurs to build, market, and sell their own online courses under their own brand. It provides comprehensive tools for course building including quizzes, assignments, and certificates, with a generous free plan and no transaction fees.
Visit ThinkificUdemy
FreeUdemy is a massive online learning marketplace with over 210,000 courses where students can purchase individual courses from various instructors across virtually any topic. It operates on a one-time payment model with lifetime access and frequent discounts, making it an affordable option for learners.
Visit UdemyFeature Comparison
| Feature | Thinkific | Udemy |
|---|---|---|
| Course Creation | Full course builder with customizable curriculum, quizzes, assignments, and certificates - you create and own your courses | Instructors can create courses but must follow Udemy's marketplace standards and compete with 210,000+ existing courses |
| Revenue Model | No transaction fees on paid plans, you keep all revenue and set your own pricing | Udemy takes a significant revenue share (up to 50-75% depending on how students find your course) |
| Branding & Customization | Highly customizable with your own branding, domain, and complete control over the student experience | Courses are listed on Udemy's marketplace under their brand with limited customization options |
| Marketing & Sales | You're responsible for marketing your own courses, though email marketing capabilities are limited | Access to Udemy's massive existing audience of millions of learners, but less control over pricing and promotions |
| Student Access | Students purchase directly from you and access courses through your branded platform | Students get lifetime access to purchased courses through Udemy's platform with mobile app and 30-day money-back guarantee |
| Course Quality Control | You maintain complete control over course quality and content standards | Course quality varies significantly between instructors with limited quality control |
Pricing Comparison
Both platforms start at $0/mo, but serve different purposes: Thinkific is for creators who want to build their own course business with full control and no transaction fees, while Udemy is a marketplace where creators trade revenue share for access to an existing audience. Thinkific requires more marketing effort but offers better long-term profit potential for serious course creators.
Verdict
Choose Thinkific if...
Choose Thinkific if you want to build your own branded online course business, keep full control over pricing and revenue, and are willing to handle your own marketing and student acquisition.
Choose Udemy if...
Choose Udemy if you want immediate access to millions of potential students without marketing effort, prefer to focus solely on course creation, or are just starting out and want to test course ideas with minimal upfront investment.
Get Your Free Software Recommendation
Answer a few quick questions and we'll match you with the perfect tools
Select the category that best fits your needs
Pros & Cons
Thinkific
Pros
- + Great free plan
- + No transaction fees
- + Highly customizable
Cons
- - Email marketing is weak
- - Checkout isn't as optimized as Kajabi
Udemy
Pros
- + Extremely affordable with frequent sales and discounts
- + Massive course library covering virtually any topic
- + One-time payment model with lifetime access
- + No subscription required for most content
Cons
- - Course quality varies significantly between instructors
- - No accredited certifications or degrees
- - Limited instructor interaction and support